I'm perfectly happy with the game overall, it's what I expected. I have the others in the series and enjoy playing. However, I have run into one level (find the match) where I could not play because the matches did not appear at all. I'm hoping it was just that one in between puzzle that had a problem and that there are no more.
No bells, no whistles, no light show or sound and fury, just a nice old-fashioned adventure. I will admit, I had to resort to a walkthrough twice (and there are both video and print walkthroughs available with a search), but was embarrassed each time, because I had missed looking in a dark spot, or had not examined a scene carefully enough. It was an interesting story, slow moving, but not boring. I enjoyed the little surprises along the way - find a new person when I went back to a scene, or figuring out how to make another person move when I needed them to get out of my way. Background sounds are spooky forest, and it is rather dark and murky, but I enjoyed it, and will probably play it again in a year or so, when I've forgotten where things were. I found it relaxing, and I recommend it - as long as one is prepared for a slow moving game that is reminiscent of old text games. Oh, there is one large spider, for those arachnophobes among us.
Favorite Genre(s):Card & Board, Hidden Object, Word
Fun Factor
2/ 5
Visual/Sound Quality
3/ 5
Level of Challenge
3/ 5
Storyline
4/ 5
Did not finish the game. I tolerated the big red X, which was annoying, and the "spot the difference" which ignored several differences, and the total illogic in repairing a ladder I needed to climb. However, the puzzle at Rebel Ray was yet another that did not work properly (about 1/3 of the puzzles), and I decided to give up. Poorly designed game, and a waste of time and money. I doubt that I will ever purchase another game in this series.
The storyline certainly isn't. The graphics aren't. The music is annoying. The "British" accents? They hurt my ears. After the witch said, "Sty or die," I'd had it. No wonder they didn't bother with more than 30 minutes of demo. I left with 12 to go.
Not anything outstanding, but fun to play another Secret City, until I came to the Bonus Game. Got stuck on the pier because I don't have a faucet handle. There was no faucet handle where I was supposed to acquire one. Can't go back, so can't finish the bonus. Very disappointing. Sorry I didn't wait for the regular edition.
I won't be playing this one again, mostly because I already had to. My brush disappeared (last chapter), and I had to reset the game to be sure to get it, to proceed until the end. The end...where I had things left in my inventory, and the end which was disappointingly abrupt. Bonus game story is confusing. I don't own cabinets where I have to break the glass to get something out, but this detective does. He also apparently breaks parts off keys often enough to have to stock spares. One person calls her own ambulance - the other recovered victims WALK to the hospital? I don't mind substituting reality for game reality, but too many things here were just plain silly. I do not think it measured up to the previous games, and I don't recommend it.
I like HOGs, and always have! So having a plain old fashioned HOG was appealing. However, it took only 1 1/2 minutes trying to play to realize that this wasn't going to work. It was so dark, I couldn't see a thing. What a disappointment.
When I did a Beta, I thought, "Great! it's the League, combined with an old fashioned HO game." And, it was for the first few scenes. As the game progressed, I was using Hint more and more, because the scenes were dark, and the object too well hidden for my old eyes - perhaps too well for my eyes when they were younger, as well because some of them are so tiny. And the repetition is getting boring. I'm not sure I will finish the game, and League of Light is one of my favorite series.
This game is the usual mix of junk pile hidden objects, and simple puzzles accompanied by cheery music, that I love. I have all the previous games. However, after my bad experience with 2 "Collector's Edition" Cruise Director games, I will wait for the SE because I see no reason to pay for extras that I may or may not be able to access. I do hope the SE is released soon, as I look forward to playing the latest in this series.
Turn off almost right away because of that really stupid gimmick – giant shell thing that eats stuff and spits out ink. @@ It had a very confused plot line and at least one puzzle had terrible directions. Why don't they all move off the island - if I can get there, they can leave. Tentacles can only reach just so far.