This game was much better than the average HOG/Adventure. I wish now that I'd bought the CE, because I really didn't want it to end. I used the harder format and so I needed a little hint now and then, but overall the game is very logical with great ambiance and voice over, and a decent length (I just wanted more).
I'm not done playing, but thought I'd put in a good review amongst a lot of negative ones. I am finding the game to have a good level of challenge, but still playable. Everything makes sense. The players voices are good, especially Giles. Enjoying it so far. I bought on sale, and am not sorry.