mcgillican's Profile
 
 
 
Stat Summary
 
  • Average Rating:
    4.6
  • Helpful Votes:
    872
 
  • Reviews Submitted:
    17
  • First Review:
    December 23, 2011
  • Most Recent Review:
    August 20, 2013
  • Featured reviews
    0
 
 
Status:
 
 
mcgillican's Review History
<<prev 1 2next
 
After being passed from one orphanage to another, all Katherine wants is a family to call her own.
 
Overall rating 
Liked it!
4 / 5
130 of 137 found this review helpful
Finally another of this series!
PostedJune 26, 2013
Customer avatar
mcgillican
fromEly, NV
Fun Factor 
Excellent
5 / 5
Visual/Sound Quality 
Good
4 / 5
Level of Challenge 
Good
4 / 5
Storyline 
Excellent
5 / 5
I loved the previous "Love Story" games and was pleased to see this game offered.
Simple, yes. Relaxing - yes! Not every HOPA has to be dark and dire. The story is sweet and that is what this game is about. The one thing I would like is for some of the dialogue to not whiz by. I do not read as fast as in my much younger days. This game has no voice over and that is ok as long as I can read the dialogue or at least recall it before moving on.
No map but this game really does not need it. Besides, a little challenge works well, and the hint button is always there.
The scenes are clear and bright.
This game will not be for those who like the dark, dreary, complicated games. This game IS for those who like lighter fare or maybe a change from the darker side of things.
I can get "immersed" in the story and find myself pushing on to see what is next.
I recommend this game!
+123points
130of 137voted this as helpful.
 
Gather evidence, interview witnesses, recreate the crime and catch the killer!
 
Overall rating 
It was OK.
3 / 5
35 of 44 found this review helpful
Had potential...............
PostedJune 26, 2013
Customer avatar
mcgillican
fromEly, NV
Fun Factor 
OK
3 / 5
Visual/Sound Quality 
OK
3 / 5
Level of Challenge 
OK
3 / 5
Storyline 
OK
3 / 5
I only played 1 "case", enough to know I really did not want to do 12 of them. The game itself had potential - to be different from other HOG games for the story and approach.
Liked no jumping back and forth.
No voice overs at all but actually, I thought the written dialogue helped retain what I needed to come to the culprit conclusion I did.
The scene graphics were ok but the music was repetitive.
No hint buttons - none needed.
The themes of the cases dealt with real life things so that is good. The caution at the beginning was warranted for younger players.
Personally, perhaps from my job background, I felt it just not challenging enough. Or maybe I watch too many crime stories and read too many crime novels. Maybe I just expected more "searching for clues".
Overall, it was not bad. It will be a fast game to complete.
+26points
35of 44voted this as helpful.
 
Search for thousands of cleverly hidden items around the historic sites of Tokyo. Play a bunch of fun mini-games too.
 
Overall rating 
Loved it!
5 / 5
237 of 271 found this review helpful
Another adventure!
PostedJune 12, 2013
Customer avatar
mcgillican
fromEly, NV
Skill Level:Intermediate
Favorite Genre(s):Hidden Object, Match 3, Mahjong
Fun Factor 
Excellent
5 / 5
Visual/Sound Quality 
Good
4 / 5
Level of Challenge 
Excellent
5 / 5
Storyline 
Excellent
5 / 5
Ok, so my eyes are old and I totally enjoy hidden object games - yes, even with no darkness and a lot of back and forth to find things. So, these Big City Adventure games always rate high with me.
A new twist this time in that you are now looking for 20 gears (don't know why yet# and with 60 rounds, obviously they are not in every scene.
The hidden objects are getting more cleverly placed with each new release of Big City Adventure. So sharpen your eyes and enjoy the fantastic graphics.
The background music is a loop and not pertinent to the game, but I mute it anyway and only listen when the family is interacting #beginning and end).
Overall, a nice peaceful way to spend some time.
I recommend this game!
+203points
237of 271voted this as helpful.
 
Solve a murder mystery involving greed and mistrust among friends in this suspenseful, back-stabbing Hidden Object game.
 
Overall rating 
Loved it!
5 / 5
9 of 11 found this review helpful
A nice break from "adventure" type HO games
PostedApril 24, 2013
Customer avatar
mcgillican
fromEly, NV
Favorite Genre(s):Adventure, Hidden Object, Match 3, Card & Board, Puzzle, Mahjong
Fun Factor 
Good
4 / 5
Visual/Sound Quality 
Good
4 / 5
Level of Challenge 
OK
3 / 5
Storyline 
OK
3 / 5
I agree with a previous review that this game is a great one and do not be discouraged from negative reviews. It is basic, yes. Objects can be small - yes. No voice overs, so what. It is much like the Agatha Christie games but without the seemingly endless dialog. Sometimes, you just need a break from running all throughout a game seeking out an object or clue. This game does just that - gives you a break. The "kiss" theory here - keep it simple, silly. You can always immerse yourself in tougher games after a simple HO game!
I recommend this game!
+7points
9of 11voted this as helpful.
 
Return once more to the haunted grounds of Ravenhearst Manor to uncover new details about this poignant saga. What you find could very well be the final chapter of this riveting story-if you escape.
 
Overall rating 
It was OK.
3 / 5
UGH
PostedFebruary 20, 2013
Customer avatar
mcgillican
Fun Factor 
Poor
2 / 5
Visual/Sound Quality 
OK
3 / 5
Level of Challenge 
Good
4 / 5
Storyline 
Good
4 / 5
Collector Edition definitely not worth buying. The strategy guide is useless. Pictures in it fine but no narrative to help you out of being stuck.
Expect more for a guide.
Hint buttons also of no use unless in MOS (which is not my fave with my aging eyesight).
Art work is ok, the cacophony of sound is intended I am sure (for making it bizarre). Too much running around without a map.
I don't recommend this game.
0points
0of 0voted this as helpful.
 
Romantic Paris awaits you on your next Big City Adventure!
 
Overall rating 
Loved it!
5 / 5
137 of 156 found this review helpful
Return to travel fun
PostedDecember 21, 2012
Customer avatar
mcgillican
fromEly, NV
Skill Level:Intermediate
Favorite Genre(s):Hidden Object, Match 3, Card & Board, Puzzle, Mahjong
Fun Factor 
Excellent
5 / 5
Visual/Sound Quality 
Good
4 / 5
Level of Challenge 
Good
4 / 5
Storyline 
Good
4 / 5
Following the usual Big City lines, this game is not a brain buster - just fun! No mystery to solve. Just sit back, sharpen your observation skills and learn tidbits about Paris as you go. Some items can be a challenge to find as they blend well into the scenery. This is a nice break from the darker HOS games.
I recommend this game!
+118points
137of 156voted this as helpful.
 
A bomb is aboard the Titanic II, a replica of the famous cruise ship! Search the ship and solve a 100-year old mystery!
 
Overall rating 
Loved it!
5 / 5
71 of 89 found this review helpful
Great Game
PostedDecember 23, 2011
Customer avatar
mcgillican
Fun Factor 
Excellent
5 / 5
Visual/Sound Quality 
Good
4 / 5
Level of Challenge 
Good
4 / 5
Entertaining! Got me hooked at solving the mystery! The objects are not impossible to find and the mini games range from simple to challenging.
I recommend this game!
+53points
71of 89voted this as helpful.