I've played all the EAP collectible games. Some are better than others and I liked this one. I've played the full collector edition game. I like the ghosts, the spookiness without overdoing the theatrics and the pace of the storyline. Granted the developers do take poetic license with the original EAP story, but it's expected by now. I enjoyed finding out the whole story behind the ghosts and what was happening to the McDougall family. The puzzles were not too difficult although I admit to needing a hint or 2. The graphics were well done and sound effects were within expectations. Background music was not irritating as some can be in other games I've played.
I did have to close the game and reopen at one point, because the game stopped responding, but closing and reopening was the fix. I didn't have to reboot the computer as I've had to do on a few other BF games.
The game took me approx 5 hrs to complete and although I have played hundreds of the BFG adventure/HO games and I do consider myself skilled, I did miss 4 of the collectibles.